The Sanibel Captiva Hotels area is a fantastic vacation location! Looking for a laid-back, quiet, and quaint vacation destination? Then Sanibel and Captiva Islands should fit the bill perfectly. Famous for their abundant seashells and low-key vibe, these islands have everything you need for a relaxing tropical getaway.
Sanibel Island boasts the majority of the accommodations of these islands. There are also a number of lovely resorts and hotels on Captiva Island as well.
Find yourself looking for a luxury retreat complete with a spa and award-winning restaurants? Or are you hoping for a private and quiet room that doesn’t break the bank? Sanibel and Captiva hotels have rentals that work for your needs and your budget.
Sanibel Island Hotel Map
Captiva Island Hotel Map
Here are the 16 Best Captiva and Sanibel Island hotels. This guide to help you plan out the perfect vacation.
Casa Ybel Beach Resort
Casa Ybel Resort is a Sanibel Island, Florida resort that is situated in an incredible beachfront location. From the moment you first wake up until you go to sleep at night, you’ll be able to enjoy views of the gorgeous Gulf of Mexico. If you’re looking for an extremely relaxing home base during your vacation, this Sanibel resort might just be a perfect choice.
Here you can get pampered at the spa or enjoy a waterfront meal at the Thistle Lodge. The Thistle offers brunch, lunch, and dinner. There are also tons of activities available here if you’ve gotten your fill of luxurious relaxation. You can’t help but enjoy paddleboarding, boating, kayaking, fishing, biking, pickleball, swimming, and more.
South Seas Island Resort
Are you wondering where to stay in Captiva? Consider booking a room, vacation home, or condo at one of the most popular Captiva Island resorts: the South Seas Island Resort.
South Seas resort occupies the entire northern tip of the island and is located in a nature preserve. This Captiva resort offers the best of both the Pine Island Sound and the Gulf. Without even leaving the property, you can see dolphins, manatees, and mangroves.
The resort offers guided nature walks to show you all of the must-see spots on the property.
There are also opportunities for playing tennis and volleyball, kayaking, and getting nostalgic in the arcade room. On top of that, there are two water slides for kids of all ages and three gorgeous pools.
You have a wide array of choices when it comes to accommodations at South Seas Island Resort. They offer a number of lovely condominiums, expansive vacation homes, and rooms at the waterfront Harbourside Hotel.
This is also a popular spot for destination weddings in Southwest Florida. This is because of the beautiful location and the range of accommodation options.
Sundial Beach Resort and Spa on Sanibel
Frequently topping the lists of the best Sanibel and Captiva hotels and resorts. It is obvious why with a waterfront location and many amazing amenities. The Sundial Beach Resort and Spa is clearly one of the best.
Sundial Beach Resort offers 5 different restaurants. First there is Shima Japanese Steakhouse. Second, is Sea Breeze Cafe, offering a full menu. There are also Shima To Go, Turtles Tiki Bar, and Slice of Paradise.
As far as activities go, they have it all. For instance, swim in the pool, play in the Gulf, try a game of pickleball or tennis. The Spa is also very popular.
One of the only downsides is that with so much going on at the resort, you might find it hard to leave the premises and check out some of the other amazing spots on Sanibel!
Beachview Cottages Sanibel Island
The Beachview Cottages resort is full of cottages where you can experience both old and new Florida. Each of the seaside cottages are uniquely different, offering comfortable and contemporary style, upscale amenities, as well as rustic charm.
If you’re traveling with your four-legged friend, you’ll be glad to know that the Beachview Cottages offer pet-friendly accommodations as well.
Keep in mind, these cottages on Sanibel Island don’t offer all the bells and whistles of some of the luxurious resorts. You’ll definitely enjoy that each cottage is only a few steps from a pristine and private Gulf of Mexico beach.
Island Inn on Sanibel Island
The Island Inn on Sanibel Island offers a wide range of options when it comes to accommodations. You can choose from beach cottages, hotel rooms and suites, and even monthly vacation homes.
Vacationers have been visiting this location for more than 100 years! Surrounded by the unspoiled beauty of Sanibel Island and located right on the beach. If you are looking for the ideal spot to enjoy true relaxation and the company of those around you, the Island Inn is a great option.
While you’re here, you’ll have access to a number of amenities including complimentary WiFi, 550 feet of pristine beach, heated and cool pools, and more. On top of that, there is an award-winning restaurant, bar, and lounge on the property known as Traditions on the Beach.
Complimentary beach walks with a marine biologist from the Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum are a benefit to staying. You can learn more about the wildlife, shells, and natural environment of Sanibel Island.
Kona Kai Motel
Set in a tropical garden, the Kona Kai Motel is something of a hidden gem on Sanibel Island. Conveniently located and featuring a nice pool, this is an affordable place to stay. It is clean and lovely for travelers who aren’t looking for all the bells and whistles of a traditional hotel or resort.
Away from the hustle and bustle of larger condo complexes, Pelicans Roost is a laid-back place to stay that offers exceptional privacy. Of note, each of the condos is owned individually. So there is quite a bit of variation in terms of what is offered when you book your stay.
Song of the Sea
Song of the Sea on Sanibel Island is a staple of the island that offers quiet accommodations in a two-story beachside building. There are a number of perks to staying here, including a complimentary bottle of wine, an outdoor heated pool, and free use of bikes, beach chairs, and umbrellas.
While there isn’t a restaurant at the hotel, there is a complimentary breakfast on the patio included in your stay. There are also communal gas grills outside and demi-kitchens in the rooms if you feel like saving some money on eating out.
Tarpon Tale Inn
If you’re hoping to tap into some of the charm of old Florida, consider staying at the Tarpon Tale Inn. Dating back to the early 1960s, this rustic inn offers ideal accommodations for people looking for peace and quiet.
Included with your room is the free use of two adult bikes, letting you explore the delightful trails of Sanibel Island. There are also private patios attached to the rooms which overlook lush gardens where you can find a Jacuzzi.
With the Gulf beach only 150 yards away, you can also benefit from umbrellas and chairs available to guests for all of your beach lounging needs.
Looking for easy access to Fort Myers and Fort Myers Beach in addition to Sanibel and Captiva, Florida? The Sanibel Inn is a reasonable choice. Not only is it conveniently located near the end of the Sanibel Causeway, but it’s also an oceanfront hotel. Here you can enjoy beach shelling and Gulf views any time of the day or night.
Sanibel Inn is known for top-notch dining opportunities at The Dunes Clubhouse and Dante’s Coal Fired Pizza. There are also plenty of recreational activities to participate in, including golf, pickleball, and tennis. On top of that, you can take a nature tour, relax on the beach, or get out on the water for some boating, fishing, kayaking, or paddle boarding.
‘Tween Waters Island Resort & Spa Captiva
Are you interested in Captiva Island resorts and hotels in particular? If this is the case, ‘Tween Waters is definitely worth checking out.
In operation for nearly a century, there are a wide variety of accommodations you can choose from here including suites, studios, and guest rooms. The beach cottages are probably the most beloved option. ‘Tween Captiva has 19 adorable cottages where you can enjoy perks like stone fireplaces and Gulf views.
There are also plenty of activities to engage in here if you choose to leave your cozy and charming beach cottage. Of course, you will want to canoe, paddleboard, or go parasailing or wave running, you won’t ever get bored here. Finally, while you’re at ‘Tween Waters you’ll also want to enjoy a relaxing spa treatment and dine at the famous Old Captiva House.
Sanibel Island Beach Resort
This is a clean and comfortable beachfront resort located on the eastern end of Sanibel. A nice boutique hotel, the Sanibel Island Beach Resort is near the Lighthouse and also pet-friendly!
Waterside Inn on the Beach
The Waterside Inn on Sanibel Island features large rooms and colorful coastal lodgings. Literally steps from the beach, the Waterside Inn on the Beach offers bikes to rent, friendly staff, and close proximity to the island’s many restaurants and shops.
West Wind Island Resort
There is something truly unique about the West Wind Island Resort on Sanibel Island! Featuring a koi pond, a butterfly garden, and free bike rentals.
On the property, there are also two restaurants where you can find delicious eats. The Normandie Seaside Café and The Upper Deck pool bar, are well prepared to take care of you.
As well as tons of activities to participate in including boating, kayaking, fishing, and shelling.
This resort is the closest place to stay on Sanibel Island to the J.N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge. A top spot for hikers, birders, or appreciators of South Florida’s incredible natural environment.
Sanibel Sunset Beach Inn
The Sanibel Sunset Beach Inn is a sister property to the Sanibel Inn. Smaller but still beachfront, this Sanibel Island inn offers no-frills accommodations at affordable prices.
The rooms have full kitchens, screened terraces, and full kitchens. The best part about the Sanibel Sunset Beach Inn is its location right on the beach.
Captiva Island Inn Bed and Breakfast
Situated just up the block from the beach, the Captiva Island Inn’s prime location helps to make up for the fact that the cottages are in need of a little TLC.
A bit more shabby chic than some of the other Sanibel and Captiva resorts and hotels on our list. There is still a lot to appreciate about these quaint Captiva accommodations.
With full breakfasts offered in two restaurants located right next door, (RC Otter’s and the Key Lime Bistro,) you won’t go hungry staying at the Captiva Island Inn.
If you are traveling in a large group or with your family, you can rent a five-bedroom house here to fit the whole crew. Without any wi-fi and with small TVs in the cottages, this is a great Captiva Island hotel if you’re hoping to take a break from the demands of technology.