Vacation Guide to Southwest Florida

Restaurants Near Pine Island Florida: Top Dining Spots Nearby

Are you looking for one of the best restaurants near Pine Island Florida? So look no further just because you are in the right place.
If you are a tourist or finding the best restaurants in the area that is necessary for a memorable trip.

Pine Island is one of the largest islands in Florida. There are a lot of things to do on this lovely island which is peaceful and isolated and has a small town feel. With the island’s lush tropical vegetation, mangroves and three water preserves it will also attract nature lovers.

This island has four distinct communities one is Pine island center. Bokeelia, Pineland and St James City are also a part of Pine Island. Each offers its own unique charm and beauty.

If you are looking for Caribbean inspired fare, seafood and old fashioned American grub every thing you can find here. In this article we are going to explore some of the best restaurants near Pine Island Florida. So read it to know about these restaurants.

5 Best Restaurants Near Pine Island Florida

There are a lot of restaurants near this island each of them offer a unique charm and atmosphere. Top 5 to them are following:

  • Tarpon Lodge Restaurant
  • Low Key Tiki
  • Phuzzy’s Boat Shack
  • Lazy Flamingo 3
  • Island Grill

Tarpon Lodge Restaurant

The Tarpon Lodge Restaurant is located in Tarpon Lodge at 13771 Waterfront Dr Building 1 Ground Floor Bokeelia Florida. You can have dinner or lunch at this restaurant or enjoy an overnight stay with waterfront views.

Tarpon Lodge Restaurant near Pine island

There is a diverse list of menu at this four star restaurant for lunch, dinner, kids, wine and special occasions. Check out the Smoked Fish Dip if you want to taste a traditional Florida dish.

Blackened fish tacos and Gulf Pink Shrimp are available for lunch while for dinner choice range starting from the traditional Southern dish shrimp & grits to excellent catfish.

At the Tarpon Lodge Restaurant guests can also take part in a wine tasting event. Their series of global wine dinners brings vintners from around the world to exchange knowledge and tasty samples from their vines. Tarpon Lodge is perfect for those families who are looking to gather for a meal or those couples who are looking for a romantic atmosphere by the sea.
It is one of the best restaurants near Pine island Florida to eat and enjoy. You can spend memorable times with your family and friends here.

Low Key Tiki

This is a popular and locally loved restaurant in St James city that is located at 3135 String fellow Rd Mile Marker One St. James City Florida.

Both locals and visitors like the bar because of its welcoming atmosphere, beer and wine selection and waterfront views. Pickle fries or applewood smoked pulled pork four ways and buffalo chicken egg rolls are just a few of the unique dishes that are served at The Low Key Tiki. Ahi’s Tuna is one of our favorite dishes in this restaurant. When the sun sets The Low Key Tiki provides delicious casual food in an elegant setting.

Live music is also available at Pine Island’s Low Key Tiki. For the ideal dining experience there is lots of outdoor seating right by the docks.

If you want to explore the island while enjoying your cocktail then this restaurant offers two amazing bars one is Crusin and other is called Tikis. So let’s enjoy the wonderful waterfront view and delicious meal together at one place.

Phuzzy’s Boat Shack

This seaside restaurant has changed its name a few times over the years. In the beginning it was known as Double Nickel and had nickels laminated into the countertops. Later it was known as Woody’s, and in recent times it goes by the name Phuzzy’s Boat Shack. Even now we still think it’s one of Pine Island’s top restaurants.

One of Pine Island's top restaurants

It is located at 3051 Stringfellow Rd St James City Florida that has solid reviews for having delicious food and a family friendly environment. The most delicious items in their menu include Boom Boom Shrimp and Mahi Mahi sandwich. Over all their menu includes a variety of delicious apps & shareables and raw bars. The signature soup and signature salads are amazing on their menu.

If we talk about seafood they also offer a wide range of fresh seafood dishes. It includes FISH & CHIPS, ALASKAN KING CRAB and yummy FRIED OYSTERS. You can have memorable dining in this bar & grill with an amazing waterfront view.

Lazy Flamingo 3

With four locations The Lazy Flamingo 3 is a famous restaurant in Southwest Florida for both locals and tourists. This family friendly restaurant offers unique seaside fare, refreshing craft beers on tap and a diverse list of menu with a variety of choices.

For freshly caught seafood lovers this Bokeelia café serves fresh seafood including peel and eats shrimp, clams and fresh oysters on the half shell. But they also offer dishes like shrimp scampi and marinara mussels.

Burgers, wings and salads are always readily available for a plant based diet. They also offer Impossible burgers for vegan diets.
You can also bring your own catch that is cleaned gutted and ready to cook that they toss on the grill for you. Guests can come to this restaurant by car or by boat to enjoy its delicious meal.

I hope you cannot find much more classy restaurants in the whole of Florida than Lazy Flamingo 3 especially at that time when you are looking for fresh seafood.

Island Grill

The Island grill is a family friendly restaurant that is located in Winn Dixie shopping plaza at 9856 String fellow Rd St. James City Florida. This restaurant serves lunch and breakfast food all day. Its perfect atmosphere and family friendly or comfortable sitting make it a perfect place to enjoy their delicious food.

Best Restaurants Near Pine Island Florida

For breakfast customers this restaurant offers a handmade corned beef hash and grits or classic eggs benedict. They also offer a diverse range of bakery items like succulent French toast and chocolate chip pancakes.

In the lunch menu their menu includes hot and cold sandwiches, BLT or grilled cheese and loaded fries. They also offer a light as air salads, hot off-the-grill burgers and Quesadilla. A wide collection of beer and wine are also included in their menu.

Bottom Line

All in all. There are a diverse range of restaurants near Pine island Florida. We created a list of the top 5 of them that are most famous and charming. If you are big fan of seafood dishes or you are looking for a yummiest taste in this island while enjoying the seaside. Then all these restaurants are the best choice for you. With unique Caribbean style flavors and a lot of raw bar choices Pine island is a paradise for seafood lovers.

Frequently Asked Question

What are the names of the top 3 restaurants near Pine island Florida?

A great range of restaurants is located near this island. But top 3 of them are following:

  • Lazy Flamingo 3
  • Low Key Tiki
  • Island Grill

Which one is the best restaurant near Pine island Florida?

Lazy Flamingo 3 is one of the best restaurants near Pine island Florida. Because of its unique seaside fare and refreshing craft beers.

1 thought on “Restaurants Near Pine Island Florida: Top Dining Spots Nearby”

Leave a Comment


Recent Articles