Vacation Guide to Southwest Florida

Der Dutchman Restaurant in Sarasota Florida: A Tasty Journey

Der Dutchman restaurant in Sarasota Florida has won an award for being the best buffet in the whole country. People voted for it in a contest by USA. This restaurant is in a place called Pine craft where Amish people live.

They have a daily buffet with a lot of good food and readers liked their special dish of noodles over mashed potatoes. This restaurant has been serving the community for almost forty years.


Sign board of Der Dutchman restaurant in Sarasota Florida
Sign board of Der Dutchman restaurant in Sarasota Florida

The first Der Dutchman Restaurant started 54 years ago in Walnut Creek, Ohio, celebrating Amish and Mennonite traditions. In 1985 the family opened another one in Sarasota.

They serve yummy and traditional foods like boasted chicken, noodles, dressing and real mashed potatoes. At the Sarasota restaurant you can enjoy a tasty buffet and salad bar or pick from the menu.

Don’t forget to save room for a delicious slice of pie or a freshly made pastry from their bakery.

What makes Der Dutchman restaurant in Sarasota Florida special?

It’s a buffet that makes it special where they mix a lot of tasty food in a nice way. People noticed how great it was and voted it the best buffet in the country. This restaurant is in an Amish neighborhood in Sarasota called Pine craft. It invites people with a lot of different and tempting food options.

Der Dutchman’s Menu

People enjoying their meal at Der Dutchman restaurant in Sarasota
People enjoying their meal at Der Dutchman restaurant in Sarasota

The extensive menu of this restaurant offers a great range of options that allows you to customize your meal according to your preferences.

If you are craving the comfort of home cooked dishes, hearty soups or refreshing beverages then Der Dutchman has a lot of options for everyone.

Order online or call 941-955-8007 to experience the goodness of Der Dutchman’s food. Where every dish is crafted with care and served with pride.

Online Ordering Convenience

Der Dutchman now offers the ease of online ordering that ensures you get the same great comfort food and service. No matter if you are dining in or taking your meal to go. The goal of this restaurant is to make things as simple as possible. Doesn’t matter if you are on the go, head home or back to work.

Daily Features

Don’t forget to ask about Der Dutchman’s daily features that add a special touch to your dining experience.

3 Course Family Meal for 4

A large dining hall of Der Dutchman restaurant in Sarasota
A large dining hall of Der Dutchman restaurant in Sarasota

For a satisfying family meal Der Dutchman offers a 3 course option for four people. This includes one meat, two sides, a tossed salad, chocolate chip cookies and dinner rolls. Their menu lets you choose from a variety of meats and sides that ensure a meal that suits your preferences.

Meat Choices

  • Boasted Chicken
  • Grilled Chicken
  • Roast Turkey
  • Baked Ham
  • Roast Beef

Side Choices

  • Mashed Potatoes with Gravy
  • Homestyle Stuffing
  • Green Beans
  • Corn or Coleslaw
  • Mac & Cheese
  • Noodles

Additionally you can choose between white or wheat dinner rolls to complement your meal.

Delicious Soups

Der Dutchman’s soups are a warm and comforting addition to your meal. Choose from Vegetable Beef or Chicken Noodle that are available in pint, quart or gallon sizes.

Meats by the Pound

For those who want to enjoy the main course then Der Dutchman offers meat by the pound. Options include Boasted Chicken, Old Fashioned Roast Beef, Roast Turkey and Glazed Ham. Each pound serves 2-3 people.


For drinks Der Dutchman restaurant in Sarasota Florida has a lot of choices. You can get soft drinks like Pepsi, Diet Pepsi and more. They also have fresh squeezed juices like Orange Juice and Apple Juice.

If you like coffee or tea then they have that too along with Hot Chocolate. They even offer Milk both White and Chocolate. You can pick what you like.

Who runs Der Dutchman Restaurant?

Now, two of Emanuel’s daughters, their husbands and their families keep the tradition going. Led by Robert and Sue Miller and Dr. Daniel and Mary Miller Dutchman Hospitality Group has grown to include seven restaurants, four inns, seven bakeries, shops, a 500 seat theater and two wholesale food suppliers.

Shop of Der Dutchman restaurant in Sarasota
Shop of Der Dutchman restaurant in Sarasota

Bottom Line

In the end, Der Dutchman Restaurant in Sarasota Florida, is a special place. It’s not just about eating it’s about tradition and kindness.

This restaurant has a long history connected to the Amish and Mennonite ways that make it loved by locals and visitors. Their friendly Amish neighborhood to being named the best buffet in the country Der Dutchman is like a family.

When you visit you are not just having a meal. You are part of a tradition of tasty, home cooked food, happy moments and the simple joy of good meals. So if you want to enjoy their famous buffet then make your own meal.

Or having a family feast Der Dutchman welcomes you to a special place where every bite feels like coming home.

Read More Articles

IF you are in Sarasota and want to explore more places and restaurants in this city. Then our more articles from our website some top choices are following:

And there are also a lot of adventurer places in this city where you can enjoy a lot with anyone. Like the Siesta Key Electric Bike Sunset Tour and Siesta Key Kayak Tour. One of the most amazing and will be memorable adventures for you is the TreeUmph Adventure Course. Must try all of these if you really want to enjoy your visit in Sarasota.

Leave a Comment


Recent Articles